SMALL PHONE
PHONE
TABLET
DESKTOP
LARGE DESKTOP
XL DESKTOP

Affordable car insurance for new drivers

Young woman coming out of car
Young woman coming out of car
Author - Robert Yeiser
Dairyland - Assistant Vice President of Market Development and Distribution
October 15, 2024

Becoming a new driver is an exciting milestone, but it comes with a few challenges. One of the most common is finding affordable car insurance as a newly licensed driver. Although vehicle insurance is a necessity, deciphering the coverages and costs can feel overwhelming.

Get insured
Auto

Good news! You can find cost-effective auto insurance without straining your wallet. We’ll share tips to help you score great rates, keep your premiums low, and also highlight some of the best options for those just starting out behind the wheel.

Why do new drivers pay more for car insurance?

New drivers often face higher insurance premiums, and understanding why can help you set realistic expectations. Insurance providers typically calculate premiums based on risk, and new drivers are seen as higher-risk due to a lack of experience. For insurers, this inexperience often translates into:

  • Higher likelihood of accidents: Statistics show that inexperienced drivers, especially teen drivers, are more likely to be involved in accidents compared to those with more driving experience.

  • No driving history: Insurers rely on driving history to assess risk. Without a record, newer drivers may face higher premiums as a precaution.

  • Vehicle type: Newly licensed drivers often choose less expensive older or used cars, or vehicles handed down to them, which may lack modern safety features that can lead to higher insurance costs.

Unlock the best car insurance rates with smart shopping

Comparison shopping is one of the simplest ways for new drivers to discover great deals. By exploring multiple options, you might be surprised at the cost differences for similar coverage options. Here are a couple of key methods to help you make the most of your insurance search:

1. Consult with an insurance company.

Handshake

Connecting with a knowledgeable insurance broker can be a game-changer for new drivers. They can offer personalized guidance and help you navigate the options to find the best deals tailored just for you. Having an experienced ally in your corner can potentially save you time and money in the long run.

2. Ask friends and family.

People with one waving

Your personal network can be one of your best resources when searching for car insurance. Chances are, someone you know has recently gone through this process. Ask about their experience—who they insure with and why they chose that provider. Also, a family member, such as a parent, may be able to add you to their existing policy, which could lead to valuable savings for both of you.

Indigo car and shield
Easy, affordable car insurance.

Tips for new drivers to get affordable car insurance

Finding affordable car insurance as a new driver might seem challenging, but you have plenty of ways to lower your costs. Whether you're just starting out or looking to switch providers, these four smart strategies can help you lock in coverage that fits your budget.

1. Consider high deductibles

Opting for a higher deductible can be an effective way to lower insurance premiums. While this increases the out-of-pocket expense in case of a claim, it can substantially reduce your monthly or annual costs.

2. Look for discounts

Many insurers offer car insurance discounts to help make coverage more affordable for new drivers. Some common discounts include:

  • Good student discount. If you’re in high school or college, maintaining good grades could earn you a discount. Many insurers reward students who demonstrate responsibility both in the classroom and on the road.

  • Defensive driving courses. Completing an accredited defensive driving course can demonstrate to insurers that you’re serious about safety, which could result in a discount.

3. Choosing the right vehicle

Newer drivers sometimes don’t have the luxury of choosing their first car. The type of car you drive, whether a fuel-efficient vehicle or a "gas guzzler," can significantly impact your insurance costs. Consider these factors when selecting a car:

  • Opt for safety. Cars with higher safety ratings are often cheaper to insure because insurers typically factor in the safety features when determining premiums.

  • Avoid high-performance cars. Sports cars or high-performance vehicles are usually more expensive to insure because they’re associated with higher speeds and potentially riskier driving behavior.

  • Consider older models. New cars tend to be more expensive to insure due to their higher value and repair costs. A well-maintained older vehicle may be a more cost-effective choice.

4. Keep your driving record clean

Maintaining a clean driving record is one of the most effective ways to keep your car insurance costs down over time. Avoid traffic violations, accidents, and claims, to help lower premiums as you build a history of safe driving. Even as a new driver, minimizing distracted driving and driving responsibly can lead to reduced rates.

Illustration of money and a wallet
Don't overpay for car insurance!

New drivers: We’ve got you covered

Starting your driving journey doesn’t have to be overwhelming. At Dairyland®, a brand of the Sentry Insurance Group, we understand the specific challenges new drivers face when searching for affordable coverage, including nonstandard auto insurance. We offer personalized support and competitive rates tailored to your needs, helping ensure you're not just protected but getting real value. With Dairyland, you can have the peace of mind that comes from choosing an insurer that puts your priorities first.

Related resources

Young woman test driving a new car

A new car requires new insurance. But you'll need to select the right coverage before you take the car off the dealer’s lot. We answer some common questions about buying insurance.

Young, excited driver
Want to know how experienced drivers stay focused on the road? Join us on a ride-along with Sarah, a safety-conscious driver, and learn her secrets to avoiding distractions.
Teen driving car
Worried about your teen driver? Learn how to help prevent distracted driving with practical tips, open communication strategies, and simple steps to help keep them focused on the road.

The general information in this blog is for informational or entertainment purposes only. View our blog disclaimer.